Monday, June 22, 2009

"Ego": Beyonce's Deconstructive Dick Joke

"If I Were a Boy", a slow burning double-standard jam. "Single Ladies", a fucking infectious empowerment song that's also really about getting married and that square stuff. "Diva", an "A Milli" rip-off. "Halo", a big ballad about the right kind of comfort in a relationship that happens to trump Animal Collective's "My Girls" in sentiment (word to Maltese Rubble on that point). And "Ego", a celebration of her (and through that your) dude's swagger that's also a dick joke that's also an artful balance of upholding pop expectations and going pretty crazy with them.

These songs really stick around for a while, through their initial ubiquity and then, their staying power and finally, their twisty-turny conceptual edges. They defy up-to-the-minute blogging and quick analysis. They're growers. Obvious and not so obvious, really stupid and the sort of thing to sit down with and unpack. That's to say, "Ego" is way more interesting a month or so after its release than it was when it first bombarded the radio because a song that's ostensibly a dick joke has been pounded into the ears of even the most casual listeners so much, they've probably "figured" it out.

Kanye explicitly acknowledged the obvious on the remix, but "Ego" is teasing you bluntness, a parody of pop music's double-entendres--the "joke" here is that her man's ego being "too wide" and not "fit[ting]" only works if you're talking about his penis. And that's pretty funny. The same way "to the left, to the left" wasn't directions for a dance move but a demand to get the fuck out is funny. But it's more than funny, it's sort of daring and very real and unglamourous, not only celebrating the size of a dude's dick but acknowledging the elasticity (or lack thereof) of her (or a) vagina. Weird stuff.

Towards the end of the song though, the lyrics switch-up and Beyonce begins describing her ego and how it is also, "too big", "too wide" and "won't fit"; she's in effect, "wearing" the dick which is interesting and well, gender-CRAZY. This is the same understated, gender-flipping weirdness found when The-Dream (a big part of Beyonce's recent successes) mimics the orgasm sounds of the girl he's with or "misogynist" Cam'ron dedicates a "verse to the everyday working woman" and raps it in her voice, inhabiting her worries and fears.

Production-wise, "Ego" is cut from the early 90s slow jam cloth but part of that sound stems from Prince--especially the rigid funk of the horns, the dash of 70s soul--and "Ego" is very much in the tradition of Prince's hyper-explicit not-even metaphors and gender-bending/complicating work-outs. This is all pretty standard stuff in a lot of ways, but it's oddly and subtly transgressive for popular radio and worth applauding because Beyonce really doesn't need to metaphorically graft a dick onto herself to compare herself to her man and his ego.

Sure, in one way, she's upholding expectations (though in a real bizarre way), sorta "making" herself male or connecting power to male-ness, but she's also complicating gender expectations, announcing she too has a big "ego" and connecting it to her feminine "legs" and "thighs"--maintaining an expert balance between neither gender, as well as praising her man's "ego" that never makes her second to him and even, claiming that ego for herself in the subject-change hook for the final verse.

Not every joint can be "Single Ladies" and Beyonce knows this. There's a sort of implicit rule it seems, that if you're a big-time artist with some artistic pretensions and a bajillion fans at the same time, you just don't make super-solid, awesomely one-note albums. You bounce and weave around prevailing trends, invent some new ones, and make sure to bop the foreheads of every person in every sub-market, and keep it moving all in the name of "range", "diversity", and pop-corporate synergy. That Beyonce found a place for something as curious as "Ego" in her every-song-is-a-hit arsenal is pretty extraordinary.

10 comments:

  1. Tying in with this post, what about this picture:

    http://cm1.theinsider.com/media/0/76/77/celebrity-imperfections-6.0.0.0x0.385x446.jpeg

    Beyonce is clearly not just slicing peppers, but penises. And her bigger, longer, more dangerous sword is her phallus. This is subversive, sure, but blindingly obvious at the same time. Beyonce (thinks she?) is better at being a dude that real dudes are? There are a lot of insights one could make from this. Really cool, regardless.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I've always been a big fan of this picture. I think because Beyonce's both an easy target to oppose feminism and a certain kind of simple, go-to feminist in Pop, it's easier for contrarian pricks like myself to ignore or dismiss her, but she's clearly doing a lot of really weird and interesting stuff and always balances it with good music--her dashes of "independence" or whatever are never are these pop art projects where they only work if you "appreciate" them for their message.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Brandon,

    I swear we must have the same father. I feel it, you type it. Gucci Mane, now Beyonce. No Trivia is steadily winning my vote for top Music Analysis Blog.

    Nova

    PS: Gucci Mane and OJ Da Juiceman are the Batman & Robin of Trap Music. Tell me I'm lying. Maybe a future posting title?

    ReplyDelete
  4. My interpretation of the part of the song when Beyonce changes person from "he" to "I" she starts referencing her pretty famous and large..ass. I think the video kind of confirms it considering what shes doing when she says "I can back it up."

    Either way, like you said it's a great way of being pretty unglamorous and not really caring. It's funny because you HAVE to be thinking of a dick or her ass for it to be funny.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Nova-
    Thanks!

    Akin-
    For length reasons, I left out the part about how it is/isn't her ass--weird to brag that your ass "won't fit", you know? Not that you're wrong but that it's a purposefully twisty kinda metaphor--it sorta works enough to not be about a dick (or ass) but not totally.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I guess my mind went right to the kind of common "how she fit all that in her jeans" reference when she was talking about "it won't fit". If you think of it like that it mostly works.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I have absolutely fallen in love with your blog. its official, Beyonce is one explosive lady! she has her ways with words and her body. She knows it, she owns it, she flaunts it! killer moves.. I just adore her. Ego takes the crown tho, seems Jay-Z got an 'ego' worth singing about if u know what I mean. ;)

    ReplyDelete
  8. Anita-
    Thanks! And uh yeah, wasn't there some rap sex book that never came out that compared Jay-Z's dick to a 2-Liter of Pepsi??

    ReplyDelete
  9. hahah yeah, now "too wide, too strong, it won't fit" does make sense! and Beyonce "back(s) it up"! ROTFL.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I'f i recall correctly, Jay-Z's dick is described as pretty big in Carmens book, and he was also in one of those "groupie confessions" in Ozone Magazine where someone claimed he had a huge dick (a fact that, according to said "confession", made him very lazy and full of himself as a lover, which actually works fine with the whole big ego-thing now that I think about it...)

    ReplyDelete